Makeup check

So I finally bought a foundation: Covergirl's TruBlend. I like it, but still, same we all makeup, it seems kind of cakey. I end up putting on the liquid foundation, setting it with a powder, and then when I'm all done, patting it all down with some water to make it look less cakey. End result looks okay, but I'm either not using enough or missing something. I don't look totally great, but better:
This I need more makeup around my eyes to hide the dark circles. And maybe I need a thicker foundation in general? I feel like you can still see all my faults! Ugh! I don't want to look like this for the wedding.